Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

The Sports Card Shop       at MoCo

About Us

The Sports Card Shop is your small town local shop with a global reach.

Located in New Buffalo, MI, we’re an easy drive for most residents in Michigan, Indiana, Illinois and Ohio.

Come see us every Tuesday through Sat from 10-5 and Sundays from 12-5.

If you prefer to shop from home, give us a call at 269-469-0140.  We accept major credit cards and paypal, and we can ship anywhere

Be sure to follow us on facebook, Instagram and twitter to stay updated on our new arrivals.

The Gotcher family has been serving the community for over 10 years.  

We look forward to meeting you.

Contact Us

The Sports Card Shop @ MoCo  18853

 US Hwy 12, New Buffalo, MI


email: [email protected]

We have Wax

New releases arriving weekly.  Check our facebook, instagram and twitter pages for live updates, Max and Owen's deals of the day, and random prize giveaways.  

We Have Graded Cards PSA, SGC and BGS

Both modern and vintage cards from PSA, BGS and SGC.  Give us a call at 269-469-0140 or email us at [email protected] if you're looking for a specific card.  

Our Story

We didn't know it at the time, but Owen jump-started this journey  3 years ago when he began collecting baseball cards.  His brother Max soon followed.  Of course, they needed mom and dad to take them to the card shows, card shops and retailers to buy, sell and trade their cards.  For awhile, we were just along for the ride.  At some point, Max suggested opening an ebay store, so we did.   After finding some quick success there, we put together a plan and eventually opened The Sports Card Shop for all collectors to enjoy.   We all actively work the shop, as Mom and Dad have both been in the retail business for 20+ years.  Max and Owen are learning about how to run a business, and give great customer service.  They're also having a little fun hanging out, and talking shop.